A schoolgirl died in her bed when her house was engulfed in a flames â the second suspicious fire to hit the family home in under a year.
Layla Allen, 13, was declared dead at the scene of the blaze in Prescot, Merseyside, late on April 2 last year.
She made no attempt to escape the blaze so it appeared âlikely she was asleep at the timeâ, Merseyside Fire and Rescue Service investigator Ruth Baller-Wilson told an inquest hearing.
Investigators have been unable to pinpoint an exact cause for the disaster but believe a lighter was likely used to set Laylaâs bedding alight.
The inquest heard the fire, which Laylaâs parents and five siblings survived, was the second fire to engulf the house.
Six months earlier, another âmember of the familyâ set fire to one of the beds inside with a lighter.
Coroner Anita Bhardwaj recorded an open verdict, saying police âcannot rule anything outâ.
The parents refused to allow their other children to be interviewed about the incident by the police, who the coroner said have âin effectâ been âprevented from gathering further evidenceâ.

Ms Baller-Wilson told the hearing: âItâs difficult to determine the exact sequence of events, however the burn pattern suggests this fire ignited on the bunk bed.
âThe fire ignited on the top bunk and developed within the bedding before it spread to the mattress, supported by the oxygen from an open window by the bed.
âLayla was a fit, healthy 13-year-old; she wasnât trapped and there was no reason why she wouldnât have at least been able to get down from the bunk, even if it was on fire. Therefore I believe itâs more likely she was asleep at the time.
âIf Layla did start the fire herself, there would be no reason why she wouldnât escape the room. Itâs possible that her clothes may have ignited, but I still would have expected her to get herself down from the bunk and attempt self-rescue.â

While the investigation was not able to find a definite cause of the fire, it found it was âmore likely than not that it was a live flame, such as a lighterâ.
Ms Bhardwaj said: âPolice were unable to interview the other children present in the house, and what police have said in effect is that they had been prevented from gathering further evidence, and without statements from all parties present they cannot rule out anything.
âItâs correct to say that they couldnât interview the other children because of the damage that it would cause to them.
âThat the family have indicated that interviews would cause too much harm to the children and they would have to relive the incident. This was supported by the childrenâs social care, and this prevented evidence being gathered.â
The inquest heard the fatal fire was the second blaze at the family home, the Liverpool Echo reports.
Ms Baller-Wilson said: âMerseyside Fire and Rescue Service attended the address for a fire which was determined to have been started by a member of the family.
âThat was in one of the bedrooms at the front of the house. It was believed to be [caused by] a lighter. From my colleaguesâ investigation and report, that was the most likely source of ignition.
âIt was in the bedroom at the front of the house and involved the mattress and bedding. There was a small amount of spread to the surrounding area. It did cause considerable damage and there was smoke to the front of the house.â

The fire services offered to refer the family to SAFE (Safety Advice and Fire Education), but the investigator said âsafe interventions were declinedâ by Laylaâs mum.
She said the cause of that first fire âwas put down to a child playing with a lighterâ.
Ms Bhardwaj told the family she is âconcerned about the fact that there has been a second fire within such a short period of timeâ and glad social services are involved.
âIf thereâs any help thatâs out there, that can assist you in educating them and yourselves, that needs to be considered,â she said.
âI cannot stress enough the importance of you as a family, for the children, to have the input of the fire services to give you guidance and support in keeping the children safe.
âThis is the second fire in similar circumstances within a very, very short period of time involving lighters and this time the sad consequence was Laylaâs death.â


